So many Aulia Allah left this world dreaming UNITY in the ummah.Allah knows how many more will die.
So many unless/Provided that/ifs are there obstructing this unity.One of them is a particular mindset between both Barelvi and Deobandi debator/munazrakhan/Flag bearers on different internet forum.
Nature of discussion/ their methodology/ their objective everything is a permanent obstruction.
Maulana Qasim Nanotwi (R.A) and Maulana Ahmad Raza Khan (R.A.) has reached to the AL JABBAR,AL AZIZ,ALMUHEEN,AL BASER,AL ADLU, AL QADIRU Almighty Allah.
WHO HAS ALREADY DECLARED TO DO UTMOST JUSTICE even for a ZARRA of Khair and Shar.
But following two categories of people are still in this world.
1.Deobandi debator are of firm believe that there is no chance of any mistake from deobandi ulema like Maulana Qasim Nanotwi (R.A)& Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi and others.If they accept any fault there OWN NAMAEE AMAAL Will not be accepted on the day of judgement.
If they become unsuccessful IN DEFENDING their own chance of JANNAT WILL BE SPOILED, So they are not taking any risk in this regard .
2. Barelwi debators are of firm believe that it is necessary to ensure deobandi ulema Maulana Qasim Nanotwi (R.A)& Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi and others in HELL to get their own Namaae Amal accepted on the day of judgement. If they become unsuccessful in ensuring them to hell their own chance of JANNAT WILL BE SPOILED, So they are not taking any risk in this regard .
This mindset is major cause of disunity among deobandi barelwis.
The Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) has said:
“Whoever charges a believer with unbelief is as though he had killed him” (Bukhari, 8.32: 6105. S).
“Any man who says, ‘O kafir” to his brother, one of them deserves the name” (Bukhari, 8.32: 6104. S).
Judging anyone who regards himself a Muslim to be an unbeliever is a matter not taken lightly by anyone who understands its consequences. It is difficult to think of a direr warning, and its purpose is clearly to dissuade Muslims of religion and good sense from judging anyone who professes Islam to be an unbeliever unless there is irrefutable proof.
For most of the other point of contention between barelvi and deobandi is also of the same serotype except one or two that have some substance in it.
What Barelvis should do now
. There are more than circumstantial evidence to believe that because of slow communication facility and gap confusion and misunderstanding arose between elder ulemas of last century. They should accept the real situation on ground and should think about decreasing the gap. And if any problem they have with any particular person they should take it at personal level instead of taking as group
What Deobandi should do now
For the unity of ummat They should approach their barelvi counterparts and should tell them that we are accepting the slip of pen of Ashraf Ali Thanwi, and some other ulema of last century.
They should not hesitate in it as it will not anyway decrease the status of Ashraf Ali Thanwi (Rahmatullah Alaihi) ,who has written nearly 1000 books including Translation of the Holy quran. So if with such voluminous work some slip of pen/error of judgment/ mistakes are found .It is normal and nothing unusual. He was a human being and was not free from error.
And this sort of mistake are in writing of all scholars of all groups (including deobandis and barelvis) (I have evidence for Barelvis also but Islam has commanded me to not to expose fault of any muslim that Allah has covered)
May Allah give us Hidayat and Taufeeq to prepare for the day of Qiyamah and Pul sirat.
Requesting for dua for myself and whole ummat.
